The bagel art scene in New York City is causing controversy as traditionalists clash with the new wave of bagel creations. Some popular bagels are deviating from the traditional style, leading to debates about authenticity. However, there are also bagel abstractions that push the boundaries even further. Despite the controversy, there are still unique and delicious bagels to be found, such as the stretchy and chewy bagel twists at Bagel Oasis and the Sichuan peppercorn bagel at Shelsky's Brooklyn Bagels. Knickerbocker Bagel offers an unconventional round object that resembles a bagel, and Terrace Bagels serves a sweet French toast bagel that is a delightful departure from tradition.