Tal Zlotnitsky and his family were once poster children for Jewish support for Muslim immigrants and progressive causes, but now feel unmoored politically and isolated as an Israeli-American and Jew. Zlotnitsky struggles to find allies who support both Israel and progressive values, and is hesitant to align with the pro-Israel movement due to its affinity for Trump. He voted for Democrat Kamala Harris but now feels confused and hurt as Trump returns to power. Zlotnitsky's experience reflects the challenges faced by liberal American Jews in the wake of a major attack on Israel and the rise of progressive criticism of the country.