American Jews are grappling with the question of how to respond to antisemitism and the deportation of antisemites by ICE. Many in the Jewish community have spoken out against the arrest of antisemitic students, while there is little mention of Jews working with ICE. The author argues that Jews must imagine having this conversation with their grandparents and great-grandparents who experienced the horrors of antisemitism. They believe that failing to implement consequences for antisemites and allowing antisemitism to thrive is a betrayal of the Jewish community's responsibility to ensure hate does not find a permanent home in the United States.