Charlie Hebdo magazine has released a special issue a decade after the attack that killed 12 people. The issue includes the winning entries of a cartoon competition on the theme of 'Laughing at God'. The attacks in 2015 and subsequent terrorist incidents in France have led to a decrease in the frequency of Islamist attacks, but the threat remains. The original pretext for the Charlie Hebdo murders, caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad, are now strictly off-limits to publications everywhere. The anniversary raises questions about what has changed and what remains of the international support that followed the attacks.