The politicization of the Nativity scene has damaged the precious interreligious dialogue that has been built up for over 40 years. The writer expresses concern about recent statements made by Pope Francis regarding Israel's war in Gaza and questions which side the Pope was referring to when he mentioned cruelty. The writer also discusses the negative trajectory of the Vatican Church with respect to the Jewish State and expresses concern that it may derail diplomatic initiatives and projects related to the Vatican Museum's Papal Heritage Collections.