President Trump's proposal to have all Palestinians leave Gaza and for the United States to take over the territory has been met with mixed reactions. Many consider the idea appalling and unworkable, while others see it as a negotiating tactic. The proposal has real-world consequences and could embolden Israel's far right, undermine Palestinian claims to statehood, and send concerning signals to other countries. Critics argue that the plan is politically disastrous and confirms the accusation that Israel is a 'settler colonial' project. Trump's approach to problem-solving prioritizes disruption and being seen as a problem solver, even if the consequences are not fully thought through.